What Can an Auto Repair Shop Pay for a New Customer Call?

Short answer: Take your average repair order, subtract what it costs you to do the work, and multiply what is left by the share of calls that become customers. That is the most a call can cost before the job earns you nothing. A smaller target leaves you something to keep.

An ad rep tells a shop owner that calls cost $55 each. Is that a deal, or a way to lose money slowly? The answer is not in the $55. It is in what a repair order leaves and how often a call turns into one.

Most shops can find those two numbers in an afternoon. Once you have them, you can say yes or no to any lead source in under a minute.

Free tool: The Lead Cost Calculator finds the most you can pay per call, form or message from your sale, your job cost and your booking rate. No account needed.

The two numbers that decide it

What a repair order leaves. The price the customer pays, minus parts, technician labor and anything else the job costs. Use an average from closed orders, not your best week.

Your booking rate. Out of 100 calls, how many end up as customers? This one is easy to guess wrong. Count for a stretch of time, then divide.

Multiply the two, and you have the most you can pay for each call. For the full method behind it, see how much you can afford to pay for a lead.

What the Lead Cost Calculator page shows

The tool's example is a general business.

What you enter Value
What a customer pays $1,000
Job cost per customer $400
Customers won 5
Calls, forms or messages 20
What you want to keep per customer $300
What you get Value
What you keep per customer after job costs $600 ($1,000 minus $400)
How many contacts end up buying 25% (5 divided by 20)
Most you can pay per contact before the job earns you nothing $150 ($600 times 25%)
Target to pay per contact $75 ($600 minus $300, times 25%)

The page explains the gap: "At $150 per contact, winning the customer would use up everything the job leaves after job costs, with nothing left for rent, taxes or profit."

A fictional example: a shop with a $480 average repair order

Fictional example. The shop and numbers are made up to show the math. They are not benchmarks.

A shop's average repair order is $480. Parts and technician labor cost $290. Last month, 40 calls came from one ad source, and 14 of them became repair orders. The owner wants to keep $90 from each new customer.

Line Amount
What a customer pays $480
Job cost per customer $290
Customers won 14
Calls, forms or messages 40
What you want to keep per customer $90
What you keep per customer after job costs $190 ($480 minus $290)
How many contacts end up buying 35% (14 divided by 40)
Most you can pay per contact before the job earns you nothing $66.50 ($190 times 35%)
Target to pay per contact $35 ($190 minus $90, times 35%)

Now the ad rep's $55 call. It is under the $66.50 ceiling, so the job still leaves something. But it is above the $35 target, so the shop would keep less than the $90 it wanted per customer.

Per customer, the picture is clearer. At $55 a call and 35% booking, each new customer costs about $157 to win. That is $55 divided by 0.35. Against the $190 a job leaves, it is thin. It may be fine if those customers come back, but the tool does not count what you have not seen.

Repeat business: the part the calculator leaves out on purpose

Repair shops live on repeat customers. A good first visit often turns into years of oil changes, brakes and tires. It is tempting to count all of it.

The tool does not. Its FAQ says: "The tool counts one sale. Do not add repeat sales you have not actually seen." If you have records showing how often new customers return, you can make a separate judgment about whether a first visit that barely breaks even is worth it. Just make that judgment with your own records, not a guess.

How to use the calculator

  1. Pull your average repair order from closed jobs.
  2. Estimate job cost honestly. Parts, labor, shop supplies, warranty work.
  3. Count calls and customers from one source for one period.
  4. Choose what you want to keep per customer, or leave it blank. The page says, "A blank box stays unknown, so do not enter 0 unless 0 is true."
  5. Compare the result to what you pay. The target is a total, including fees to a marketing company.

What the tool cannot do

It does not tell you whether enough calls exist at your target price. It also does not account for the hours the work takes, which is a separate limit. See our post on how many new customers your team can handle.

The page states two cautions plainly: "What you keep after job costs is not profit. Rent, taxes and other costs still count." And, "Your numbers for how many callers buy, and your plans, are your own. They are not checked or promised."

Questions shop owners ask

Should I count every call, or only calls from new customers?

Count the calls from the source you are testing. If the source brings both new and returning customers, separate them if you can. Mixed counts blur your booking rate.

What if my booking rate is very low?

Then the ceiling is low, and cheap calls matter more. It is also a prompt to check how calls are answered. Our post on calls that do not become customers covers common leaks.

Is a lower cost per call always better?

No. A cheap call that never books costs more per customer than an expensive call that does. Compare sources by cost per customer, not per call.

Do tire and oil change customers belong in the same calculation?

Not if the job values differ a lot. Run the calculator for each type of work you advertise.

What does the planner assume about my fees to an agency?

Include them. The page says, "Yes. The target is a total cost per contact." If you leave fees out, your real cost is higher than your report shows.

Find your own limit

Open the Lead Cost Calculator with your average repair order and last month's call count. If the number surprises you, we can check it against what you pay now. Talk with ThinkDMG or learn about our PPC advertising services.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *