Short answer: A special is worth running when the extra cars it brings leave you at least as much money as normal-price work would. Divide what normal-price jobs leave by what one discounted job leaves, then round up. That is how many specials you need just to break even with a normal stretch.
A $90 synthetic oil change drops to $70 for a month. The shop is busy, the phone rings, and the bays are full. At the end of the month, the owner looks at the cash and wonders why a busy month felt so thin.
The answer is usually in the arithmetic. A discount comes out of what each job leaves you, not out of the price. And the price you cut is often the part that was paying for the shop.
Free tool: The Offer Comparison Planner shows what each offer leaves and how many sales it needs to match normal-price work. No account needed.
What a discount really costs
Say an oil change costs you $45 in oil, filter and labor. At $90, the job leaves $45. At $70, it leaves $25. The price fell by 22%, but what you keep fell by 44%.
That is the heart of it, and it is why our general guide, Is this promotion worth running?, warns against judging a discount by the percentage alone. This post runs the same math for a repair shop.
What the Offer Comparison Planner page shows
The tool's example is a general service, not an oil change.
| What you enter | Value |
|---|---|
| Normal price | $100 |
| Sale price | $80 |
| Job cost | $40 |
| Gift or bonus cost | $5 |
| Cost of winning each customer | $10 |
| Sales you expect from the offer | 20 |
| Normal-price sales in the same time | 10 |
| What you get | Value |
|---|---|
| Left from each sale before marketing | $35 ($80 minus $40 minus $5) |
| Left from each sale after winning the customer | $25 ($35 minus $10) |
| Left from 20 sales after winning the customers | $500 (20 times $25) |
| What the normal-price sales left before marketing | $600 (10 times $60) |
| Sales needed to match the normal-price sales | 18 ($600 divided by $35, rounded up) |
The page is careful about what the result means: "To match what normal-price sales left you, this offer needs 18 sales. That is only math. It does not mean the offer will bring in 18 sales."
A fictional example: a $70 oil change special
Fictional example. The shop and numbers are made up to show the math. They are not benchmarks.
A shop sells a synthetic oil change for $90. The oil, filter and labor cost $45. It is considering a $70 special that includes a free tire rotation costing $6. Winning each new customer through a coupon mailer costs about $12. The shop expects 30 special sales. In a normal stretch of the same length, it does 14 oil changes at $90.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Normal price | $90 |
| Sale price | $70 |
| Job cost | $45 |
| Gift or bonus cost (free tire rotation) | $6 |
| Cost of winning each customer | $12 |
| Sales you expect from the offer | 30 |
| Normal-price sales in the same time | 14 |
| Left from each sale before marketing | $19 ($70 minus $45 minus $6) |
| Left from each sale after winning the customer | $7 ($19 minus $12) |
| Left from 30 sales after winning the customers | $210 (30 times $7) |
| What the normal-price sales left before marketing | $630 (14 times $45) |
| Sales needed to match the normal-price sales | 34 ($630 divided by $19, rounded up) |
Even if the shop gets the 30 specials it expects, it needs 34 just to match what 14 normal oil changes would have left. And after the $12 cost of winning each customer, 30 specials leave $210. Fourteen normal jobs would have left $630 before any marketing cost.
None of this means the special is a mistake. It means the shop should go in knowing that it needs more than 30 cars, and that it needs the bay time to do them.
The checks a discount often skips
Can you handle the extra cars? Thirty-four oil changes take bay and technician time. If the extra time pushes out higher-value repairs, the special costs more than the math shows. Our post on how many new customers your team can handle covers the time limit.
Will the customers come back? Many shops run a special to start a relationship. That can be a good reason. But the tool does not guess it for you. Its FAQ says, "Enter any repeat sales on their own. The tool does not guess how many customers come back or what they are worth over time." If you have seen returning customers, add them as a separate line. If you have not, do not count them.
Is the cost of winning the customer in the math? Mailers, coupons, ads and the staff time to process them all count. Leave it out and the special looks better than it is.
Is the original price honest? If a "was" price was not a price you actually charged, the discount may mislead customers. Check your state and local rules on advertised prices before you print.
How to use the planner
- Start with the normal job. Enter the price and what it costs you.
- Enter the special's price, and any gift. Include the free rotation, the coupon or the loaner.
- Add the cost of winning each customer if you know it. If you do not, leave it blank. The page says, "the totals that need them stay blank."
- Enter how many specials you expect and how many normal sales you do in the same time.
- Read the matching number, and ask whether you can really reach it.
What the planner cannot do
The page says it "does not pick a winner" and "does not predict demand or how many people use the offer." If a special "leaves you nothing on each sale, the matching-sales math does not work." And what is left "is before rent, taxes and other costs. It is not profit."
Questions shop owners ask
Does the share of customers who use the coupon change the math?
Not the discount. The page says, "If you enter it, you get a plan for expected uses. The discount is not taken off a second time." Enter the sales you expect and keep the price the same.
What if my special leaves me less than I need but brings in new customers?
That can be a decision you make on purpose. Just make it with the numbers in front of you, and set a limit on how long you will run it. Our post on testing one change at a time shows how to run a special as a trial.
Should I discount the oil change or add something to it?
An added item, like a tire rotation, still costs you. It belongs in the gift or bonus line. Compare both versions in the planner and see which leaves more.
How long should a special run?
Long enough to count results, short enough that regulars do not wait for the next one. Pick an end date before you start.
Can I use the planner for other services?
Yes. Brakes, alignments, inspections and tires all work the same way. Enter the price, the cost and the offer.
Check your own special
Open the Offer Comparison Planner and enter your next special before it goes to print. If you want help planning a promotion that makes sense for your shop, we can look at it together. Talk with ThinkDMG or learn about our PPC advertising services.