Is This Promotion Worth Running? How Many Extra Sales a Discount Needs

Most owners assume a 20% discount needs about 20% more sales to pay for itself. It usually needs a lot more than that, because the discount comes out of your margin, not out of your price.

That gap is why some promotions keep the crew busy and still leave the month thinner than a normal one. The math to check it is simple, and it is worth doing before the flyer goes to print.

Short answer: A promotion is worth running only if it brings in enough extra sales to make up for the smaller amount each sale leaves you. Take what your normal-price sales leave after job costs, divide it by what one discounted sale leaves, and round up. That is how many promotional sales you need just to break even with a normal month.

Why a discount costs more than it looks

A discount does not come off your price. It comes off what is left after the job is paid for.

Say a job sells for $100 and costs $60 to do. You keep $40. Take 20% off the price and you sell it for $80. The job still costs $60, so you now keep $20. A 20% price cut just cut what you keep in half.

That is the whole idea behind our free Offer Comparison Planner. The tool page puts it this way:

"See how many sales a discount or special needs to leave you the same money as normal-price sales."

The math the tool uses

Here is the method, quoted from the tool page:

"What each sale leaves before marketing is the sale price minus the job cost and gift cost. Subtract the cost of winning the customer to see what is left after marketing. Sales needed to match normal-price sales are what those sales left, divided by what one offer sale leaves, rounded up."

As steps:

  1. Left from each offer sale before marketing = sale price − job cost − gift or bonus cost
  2. Left after winning the customer = step 1 − cost of winning each customer
  3. What normal-price sales left = number of normal-price sales × (normal price − job cost)
  4. Sales needed to match = step 3 ÷ step 1, rounded up

The tool's own worked example

This is the example published on the tool page. The numbers are made up and are not a forecast.

What you enter Value
Normal price $100
Sale price $80
Job cost $40
Gift or bonus cost $5
Cost of winning each customer $10
Sales you expect from the offer 20
Normal-price sales in the same time 10
What you get Value
Left from each sale before marketing $35 ($80 minus $40 minus $5)
Left from each sale after winning the customer $25 ($35 minus $10)
Left from 20 sales after winning the customers $500 (20 times $25)
What the normal-price sales left before marketing $600 (10 times $60)
Sales needed to match the normal-price sales 18 ($600 divided by $35, rounded up)

Ten normal-price sales left $600. The offer needs 18 sales to leave the same, nearly double the volume. The tool is careful about what that number means:

"To match what normal-price sales left you, this offer needs 18 sales. That is only math. It does not mean the offer will bring in 18 sales. Check that you can handle the work and pay for the offer."

A fictional example: comparing four discounts and a bonus

Garden State Gutter Co. is a made-up business. Every number below is an assumption for teaching.

  • Normal price for a gutter cleaning: $250
  • Job cost (labor, fuel, disposal): $110
  • Normal-price sales in a typical month: 30
  • What those 30 sales leave before marketing: 30 × $140 = $4,200

The owner wants a spring special and is weighing a few versions. The tool lets you compare up to three offers at once, so this is the kind of side-by-side it is built for.

Offer Sale price Left per sale Sales needed to match $4,200 More sales than normal
10% off $225.00 $115.00 37 23% more
15% off $212.50 $102.50 41 37% more
20% off $200.00 $90.00 47 57% more
25% off $187.50 $77.50 55 83% more
Full price + $15 bonus $250.00 $125.00 34 13% more

Sales needed are rounded up. "More sales than normal" compares to the 30 normal-price sales. These are fictional calculations, not predictions.

Two things stand out.

First, the climb is steep. Going from 10% off to 25% off does not add a little more work. It takes the break-even point from 37 sales to 55.

Second, the bonus option needs the fewest extra sales. A free add-on that costs $15 to deliver (say, a downspout flush) leaves far more per sale than knocking $50 off the price. Whether customers find the bonus as appealing as a discount is a separate question, and only a real test can answer it. But the math says it is worth considering.

The capacity check most promotions skip

At 20% off, Garden State would need 47 jobs to match a normal month. Can the crew do 47 gutter cleanings in that month? If the answer is no, the promotion cannot break even no matter how well it sells.

Before you run any special, check your open hours with the Advertising Capacity Calculator. Our guide on how many new customers your team can handle walks through it.

Include the cost of winning the customer

A promotion still has to be advertised. Ads, flyers and postcards cost money, and that cost comes out of each sale too.

In the gutter example, if it costs about $25 in marketing to win each promotional customer, the 20% offer leaves $90 − $25 = $65 per sale after marketing. That is less than half of the $140 a normal sale leaves before marketing.

If you are not sure what you can afford to pay to win a customer, our guide on how much you can afford to pay for a lead covers that math.

When a promotion still makes sense

The math is not an argument against all discounts. Some promotions earn their keep in ways a single month does not show:

  • Filling a slow season. If the crew would otherwise sit idle, a sale that leaves less per job may still beat no job at all.
  • Starting a repeat relationship. A first-time discount can be worth it if those customers come back at full price. The tool does not guess this for you:

"Enter any repeat sales on their own. The tool does not guess how many customers come back or what they are worth over time."

  • Moving a specific service. A special on an add-on can raise the average ticket if it rides along with full-price work.

The key is to name the reason up front and check it afterward with real numbers, not hopes.

Keep your "was" price honest

If your ad says "was $250, now $200," the $250 needs to be a real price you actually charged. Federal guidance on comparison pricing starts from a simple idea: "Where the former price is genuine, the bargain being advertised is a true one" (16 CFR 233.1). If your business makes price comparisons often, it is worth a quick review with your attorney. This is general information, not legal advice.

How to use the Offer Comparison Planner

  1. Pick the time period. A month is a good default.
  2. Enter up to three offers. For each, enter the normal price and either the sale price, a dollar discount or a percent discount.
  3. Enter job cost and any gift or bonus cost. Use what it really costs you to deliver the work.
  4. Add the cost of winning a customer, if you know it. If not, leave it blank. The tool will not treat blank as zero.
  5. Add normal-price sales in the same period. This is what the offer has to match.
  6. Compare the "sales needed" numbers. Then check them against your capacity.

The tool will not choose for you:

"The tool does not pick a winner. It does not predict demand or how many people use the offer."

Questions owners ask

Does the share of people who use the offer change the math?

The tool page answers this directly: "If you enter it, you get a plan for expected uses. The discount is not taken off a second time."

Is "what is left" my profit?

No. It is what is left after the job cost, the gift cost and the cost of winning the customer. Rent, insurance, taxes and other overhead still have to come out of it. The tool says so plainly: "It is not profit."

What if the offer leaves nothing per sale?

Then no number of sales can match a normal month. The tool says the matching-sales math "does not work" in that case, which is a useful warning on its own.

Run your offer before you print it

Try your own numbers in the free Offer Comparison Planner. Compare up to three versions of your promotion side by side, then check the winner against your open hours.

If you want help deciding which offer to test and how to advertise it, talk with ThinkDMG. We can help you set up a promotion with a clear goal, a spending limit and a way to measure what it actually brought in. Learn more about our paid advertising services.

Comments are closed.